If you are "overqualified"
If you are a high-skilled worker such as a computer programmer, reach the
age of 40, or have more than 10 years of experience, and don't want to go into
management, then you will be confronted with being rejected for jobs for being
"overqualified". Recent surveys of hiring managers show that more
than 95 percent of them either have never hired anyone with more than 10 years
experience, or would not consider doing so. There is no easy way of getting
around this problem. You just have to adapt to it the best way you can.
The first thing you need to do is understand what is going on. Here are the
salient elements:
- Rejection for being "overqualified" is a fairly recent cultural
development. There was no such thing before the 1970s.
- "Overqualified" is not just about age, although those over 40 may
be presumed to be "overqualified".
- HR professionals, who are also a fairly recent development, and many hiring
managers, would rather leave a job undone than risk being criticized for making
a "bad hire". There is no downside for reporting that no one could be
found to fill the position.
- Hiring managers often have a personal agenda that differs from the best
interests of their company, and a worker who has more skills or knowledge than
the minimum needed to do the job may be a threat to the hiring manager and the
established order in the department. This attitude has been expressed by some
in such words as, "They've seen it all and want to show you how it's
done."
- Highly experienced technical workers are also seen as misfits by
co-workers. As a manager once put it, "It doesn't work to start a senior
guy at an entry level because he knows too much, and sets a standard the others
can't match, but if we start him at a high level the others resent him for not
having come up though their ranks. It is easier to just avoid the problem by
not making the hire."
- Hiring managers will usually prefer to fill a position with someone
underqualified, or leave the job undone, than hire someone who is
"overqualified".
- The myth that "overqualified" workers are more likely to leave
for a better job is just that. Nonoverqualified workers are just as likely to
leave. It is only the incompetents who cling to the job. But the myth is deeply
entrenched.
- It is not about obsolete skills, and retraining is not the solution, unless
it is for working in an entirely different field, such as carpentry.
- Discrimination against the "overqualified" is relentless. Don't
believe protestations that they don't discriminate on the basis of age or
experience or "overqualification", or when they point to a token
"old guy". They are lying.
The second thing you need to do is plan for becoming
"overqualified". Don't wait until you get laid off and find it takes
two years to get the next job.
- Plan your career move. Basically, there are only three alternatives if you
haven't become rich enough to retire:
- Move into management, but the supply of management jobs is limited compared
to high tech skilled jobs.
- Become an incorporated contractor and go into business for yourself. If you
do, you had better have your own product, because clients tend to discriminate
against over-40 contract workers as well, although not as much.
- Move into another field, such as construction work, but be prepared for
seasonal layoffs.
- Save money, have sources of financing, and keep your overhead low. You may
be out of work for six months between jobs in your twenties or thirties, but
that will increase to a year or two, perhaps more, as you approach 40. Don't
run out of money and become homeless. It is probably better not to have a
family or a mortgage that will tie you down to a place where there isn't any
work.
- Don't plan on company "benefits" being there when you need them.
For every company that makes its workers rich when it goes IPO, there are
hundreds that will lay you off just before the benefits vest. Get it in cash,
and exercise the stock options as soon as you can. If you invest, invest in
land where you can survive by living off the land.
- Even if you get rich, don't count on remaining so. Eventually the
government or some crooked lawyer will find a way to take it all away from you,
or the economy will go bad and make your investments worthless. The only
security is basic survival skills, and if you can't keep anything else, hang on
to your firearms.
- Take care of your health. Get and keep a health insurance policy. Exercise,
eat right, don't smoke or drink.
- Make friends with people who have skills and resources complementary to
yours, so you can form a mutual aid community if things get bad. A family can
serve that purpose, but is less likely to do so today than in ages past.
- Make your motor vehicle a van you can live in if it comes to that, keep it
well-maintained, and learn to do your own repairs.